Skip to content

featuring historical research, writing, and media at st. mary's university

  • World History

    World History

    Menu
    • World History
    • Pre-Classical History (to 600 BCE)
    • Classical History (600 BCE-600 CE)
    • Post-Classical History (600 CE-1492 CE)
    • Early Modern History (1492-1789)
    • Modern History (1789-1914)
    • Global History (1900-present)

    From the Ancient World

    Prehistoric Life, Medicine, and Its Dangers

    Posted by Ian Mcewen04/16/2021

    From the Modern World

    Rwanda Climbs One Hill After Another, But Can It Politically Transition Without Falling?

    Posted by Raul Colunga04/18/2021

    Regional Histories

    Menu
    • African and African American Studies
    • Latin American Studies
  • US History

    Early America

    Menu
    • US-Three Worlds Meet (to 1620)
    • US-Colonization and Settlement (1585-1763)
    • US-Revolution and the New Nation (1754-1820s)
    • US-Expansion and Reform (1801-1861)
    • US-Civil War & Reconstruction (1850-1877)

    Jackie Robinson: An Unexpected Hero of Business and Civil Rights

    Posted by Todd Brauckmiller Jr.11/01/2019

    Can We All Get Along?: The Fight Against Police Brutality

    Posted by Lindsey Ogle11/23/2020

    Live Rattlesnakes and Rock n' Roll: The Story of ZZ Top's "Worldwide Texas Tour"

    Posted by Ricky Moreno10/22/2020

    Bonnie and Clyde's Darkest Hour

    Posted by Sebastian Portilla11/15/2019

    Calculating the Death of Learning

    Posted by Sabrina Doyon11/08/2019

    Déjà vu: “Have I been here before?”

    Posted by Emilia Caballero Carmona04/14/2021

    America's Fallacy for the Poor: Innocent Until Proven Guilty

    Posted by Miranda Yzaguirre12/01/2020

    Deco Districts and Community Identity: Historic Designation and Preservation of Art Deco Architecture

    Posted by Edgar Velazquez Reynald05/31/2019

    Howard Schultz: Brewing a Multibillion Dollar Empire

    Posted by Andrea Laguna04/12/2021

    "You have the right to an attorney..." or Not

    Posted by Kacey Diaz03/06/2020

    San Antonio Royalty: The Reign of the Chili Queen

    Posted by Sara Ramirez04/07/2019

    The Lone Star State: The Reality of Gun Legislation In Texas

    Posted by Sofia Almanzan03/30/2020

    Bad Boys vs. Archangels - Adapting and Overcoming the 'Jordan Rules'

    Posted by Stephen Talik04/17/2020

    West Side Illumination: The Teatro Alameda and the Exhibition of Mexican Cinema in San Antonio

    Posted by Edgar Velazquez Reynald08/22/2019

    Edward Snowden: The Inside Scoop On The World's Most Infamous Whistleblower

    Posted by Ryan Estes04/04/2019

    ¡Si, Se Puede! – Collective Organizing, Unions, and Non Violent Protests

    Posted by Eric Grant11/19/2020

    Five Eyes & An Onion: Tor & the Deep Dark Web

    Posted by Stephen Talik04/08/2020

    Walt Disney and the building of his Magic Kingdom

    Posted by Malik Heard12/06/2019

    The Prosecutor Who Took On The Dream Team

    Posted by Ariana Brown11/26/2019

    Jaime Cuervo: La Opresión Ignorada Del Latinoamericano

    Posted by Matthew Bennett11/25/2020

    Elaine Brown and the Hidden Truths of the Black Panther Party

    Posted by Mia Morales05/10/2019

    America's Greatest Escape: Alcatraz

    Posted by Shea Slusser11/12/2019

    Plague! Plague! Plague!

    Posted by Jacqueline Mendez12/10/2019

    Factory farms are not the way to go

    Posted by Maria Moreno04/18/2021

    Phineas Gage: An Ordinary Man

    Posted by Stephanie Cerda10/02/2019

    Racism is a Public Health Emergency

    Posted by Hailey Lechuga04/18/2021

    Fyre Festival: Trouble in Paradise

    Posted by Chelsea Alvarez05/12/2019

    The Exorcism of Roland Doe

    Posted by Mitchell Yocham12/05/2019

    Quiet Man On the Run: The Story of Frank Abagnale, World-Renound Con-Artist

    Posted by Lilia Seijas11/01/2019

    The Hondo Hurricane and the "Shot Heard 'Round the World"

    Posted by Gwyn Hartung04/14/2021

    Contemporary America

    Menu
    • US-Industrial United States (1870-1900)
    • US-Emergence of Modern America (1890-1930)
    • US-Great Depression & WWII (1929-1945)
    • US-Postwar United States (1945-early 1970s)
    • US-Contemporary United States (1968-present)
  • Themes

    SPICE Categories

    Specialty Categories

    Special Themes

    Menu
    • Social History
    • Political History
    • Environmental History
    • Cultural History
    • Economic History
    Menu
    • Art History
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Gender Studies
    • Human Rights
    • Public Health and Medicine
    • International Relations
    • Linguistics
    Menu
    • Military History
    • Music
    • People
    • Psychology
    • Religion
    • Science & Technology
    • Sports
    Menu
    • Catholic Heritage
    • The Year 1968
    • COVID-19
    • Social Justice
    • Spanish Language
  • Showcase

    Showcase Editions

    • Vol 1 – 2016
      • Vol 1 No 1 Aug-Sep 2016
      • Vol 1 No 2 Oct-Nov 2016
    • Vol 2 – 2017
      • Vol 2 No 1 Jan-Feb 2017
      • Vol 2 No 2 Mar-Apr 2017
      • Vol 2 No 3 Aug-Sep 2017
      • Vol 2 No 4 Oct-Nov 2017
    • Vol 3 – 2018
      • Vol 3 No 1 Jan-Feb 2018
      • Vol 3 No 2 Mar-Apr 2018
      • Vol 3 No 3 Aug-Sep 2018
      • Vol 3 No 4 Oct-Nov 2018
    • Vol 4 – 2019
      • Vol 4 No 1 Jan-Feb 2019
      • Vol 4 No 2 Mar-Apr 2019
      • Vol 4 No 3 Aug-Sep 2019
      • Vol 4 No 4 Oct-Nov 2019
    • Vol 5 – 2020
      • Vol 5 No 1 Jan-Feb 2020
      • Vol 5 No 2 Mar-Apr 2020
      • Vol 5 No 3 Aug-Sep 2020
    Menu
    • Vol 1 – 2016
      • Vol 1 No 1 Aug-Sep 2016
      • Vol 1 No 2 Oct-Nov 2016
    • Vol 2 – 2017
      • Vol 2 No 1 Jan-Feb 2017
      • Vol 2 No 2 Mar-Apr 2017
      • Vol 2 No 3 Aug-Sep 2017
      • Vol 2 No 4 Oct-Nov 2017
    • Vol 3 – 2018
      • Vol 3 No 1 Jan-Feb 2018
      • Vol 3 No 2 Mar-Apr 2018
      • Vol 3 No 3 Aug-Sep 2018
      • Vol 3 No 4 Oct-Nov 2018
    • Vol 4 – 2019
      • Vol 4 No 1 Jan-Feb 2019
      • Vol 4 No 2 Mar-Apr 2019
      • Vol 4 No 3 Aug-Sep 2019
      • Vol 4 No 4 Oct-Nov 2019
    • Vol 5 – 2020
      • Vol 5 No 1 Jan-Feb 2020
      • Vol 5 No 2 Mar-Apr 2020
      • Vol 5 No 3 Aug-Sep 2020
  • About

    Course Readings

    Article Indexes

    About Us

    Menu
    • Course Readings – SC 3300 – Nash
    • Course Readings – SMC 1301 – Wieck
    • Course Readings – PO 4334 – Dr Celine
    • Course Readings _ PO 3365 – Dr Celine
    Menu
    • Course Readings – HS 2321 – Whitener
    • Course Readings – HS 2322 – Whitener
    • Course Readings – SMC 1301 – Whitener
    Menu
    • Our Article/Author Index
    • Award Winning Articles
    Menu
    • Our StMU History Media Project
    • Our Faculty Consultants
    • Our Writers
    • Contact Us
  • Cultural History, Descriptive Article, Global History (1900-present), Music, People, Political History, World History
  • November 2, 2019

Fighting Soviet Socialism With Music: Shostakovich

Screen Shot 2019-10-21 at 10.00.17 AM
Amanda Uribe

Amanda Uribe

What really happened on December 11, 1936 will forever be a mystery to the music world. At the height of Soviet oppression of the arts, Dmitri Shostakovich, a very influential composer in the early twentieth century, took a strong stance against the Soviet Union and Joseph Stalin’s rule. He used his music to speak his mind, and it was rumored that his 4th Symphony would be his loudest, most ambitious piece that he had ever composed. The symphony even called for over one-hundred instruments.1 However, on the day of its debut, Shostakovich abruptly cancelled it. The symphony would not be performed for over two decades. But given how significant the piece was to him, why did Shostakovich cancel it?

Shostakovich spent most of his life in the public eye. He was first introduced to music by his mother, who was a pianist. At eight years old, his mother put him in front of a piano and realized that he was gifted with perfect pitch and an impressive memory that allowed him to play exactly what she had taught him. At only thirteen years old, Shostakovich attended school at St. Petersburg Conservatory, where he started to write and compose music.  He was nineteen when his first symphony debuted. It was a huge success and it kick started his music career. From that point on, Shostakovich had become famous.2

From left to right: Sergei Prokofiev, Dmitri Shostakovich and Aram Khachaturian, 1945 | Russian State Archive of Literature and Art, Moscow | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

By 1931, Shostakovich had composed ballets, operas, film scores, orchestral pieces, and two new symphonies. His art was pure self expression and he was loved by the public. He had so many plans for his next compositions, and he even started to compose music for Lady MacBeth of Mtsensk, the famous Shakespearean tragedy that was being turned into an opera.3 Shostakovich dedicated the opera to his new bride, Nina, and he poured his heart into it.4 It took him several years to fully finish it because of how much sentiment it had for him. But little did he know, that in these years, his art would become completely restricted and even threatened by the Soviet Union.

The Soviet Union was notorious for censorship of the arts, and especially of self expression. In August of 1934, Joseph Stalin declared Socialist Realism as the only form of art that the Soviet Union condoned. Socialist Realism was an established form of art that promoted propaganda for the Soviet Union, and for the Communist Party’s ideals. Its art was described as artificial and narrow. It was ruthlessly enforced by the Soviet Union, and it was the start of a severe censorship of the arts.5 Unfortunately for Shostakovich, and for other Russian artists who did not agree with the Soviet regime and its Socialist Realism, it made them huge targets for Stalin. But that did not stop Shostakovich from finishing his work on Lady MacBeth of Mtsensk.

Lady MacBeth of Mtsensk was monumental. The opera was very progressive and focused on the defiance of a woman who wanted to be free from her marriage. It was interpreted that the opera was blurring social norms for women and music. It was described as vivacious, sexual, and highly creative. It was the complete opposite of Socialist Realism, and following its debut, it was an instant success. The public liked it so much, that it was performed over two-hundred times, and each performance filled over 90% of the theater’s capacity.6 Critics loved Lady MacBeth of Mtsensk and the work Shostakovich put into it. Some critics even said it was the best art that Russia had seen in over half a century. But Shostakovich soon faced the repercussions of a harsher critic. On January 26, 1936, Joseph Stalin and several highly ranked officials abruptly showed up to a performance of Lady MacBeth and left before the opera had even finished.7 It was a clear sign of turmoil. Two days after the performance, Russia’s official newspaper, Pravda, came out with the article “Muddle in Music,” that bashed Lady MacBeth of Mtsensk and more importantly, Shostakovich himself.8

Portrait of Dmitri Shostakovich, July 28, 1950 | Photo by Roger Gössing | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Joseph Stalin took a personal interest in Shostakovich. Not even two weeks after “Muddle in Music” appeared, a new article from Pravda, “Balletic Falsity” bashed another piece Shostakovich had worked on. The end of the article displayed a chilling message. Saying “This is a game… that may end very badly.”9 This was a formal threat from Stalin to Shostakovich and it instilled fear in everyone that publicly endorsed Shostakovich. After this, Shostakovich kept a packed suitcase in front of his door; he feared that he would be arrested or even killed by Stalin and the secret police.10 After all of this, his career tanked. His own friends started to disassociate themselves from him because of their own fear of Stalin and what would happen to them if they continued their friendship and loyalty to him. This fear stemmed from The Great Purge, which was a campaign of political repression led by Joseph Stalin that resulted in over two million arrests, and over seven-hundred thousand executions from 1935 to 1938. These deaths were inflicted on anyone that opposed Stalin and his grip on power. Simply being friends with someone who opposed Stalin was reason enough for arrest.11 Shostakovich was not unscathed by Stalin’s purges. Many of his friends disappeared. While going through such panic, he turned to composing his 4th Symphony.

Shostakovich knew that his defiance of Socialist Realism had inspired many people. As a result, he was a huge target for Stalin’s thugs, and he knew that he had to stand against them. They took his career, his friends, his safety, and his freedom away from him. Although Stalin could take all of those things, he could never take away his passion and gift of composing music. Shostakovich started composing his 4th Symphony in September of 1935, just as the purges were starting up. He put it on hold when he started to work on Lady Macbeth. In February of 1936, Shostakovich was still dealing with the repercussions of Pravda’s articles. He knew that Stalin would have a close eye on what he would compose next. Despite knowing that, he continued to write the 4th Symphony. The symphony would be the loudest piece he would ever compose. Not only was the music itself loud, but the message was astonishing. He had gone through so much during the months leading up to the completion of the 4th, and he would forever be changed by it. Shostakovich planned to meet with Otto Klemperer, a Jewish composer, on May 30, 1936, to show him the 4th Symphony. In the early morning of May 30, Shostakovich’s wife gave birth to their daughter, Galina. After celebrating the birth of his first child, Shostakovich returned to performing the 4th Symphony for Klemperer and other acquaintances. They instantly loved it and Fritz Stiedry promised to perform it in Leningrad. Shostakovich was happy that they liked it, but he deeply feared the reality of what could happen after its debut.12

From left: Mstislav Rostropovich, Dmitry Shostakovich and Svyatoslav Richter, People’s Artists of the USSR | November 1, 1968 | Photo taken by Mikhail Ozerskiy | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

In the months leading up to the 4th Symphony’s debut, Shostakovich would “tremble with fright.”13 The date of debut was set for December 11, 1936. Having recently become a father, Shostakovich knew that he had a lot to lose. On the morning of December 11, Shostakovich abruptly cancelled the 4th Symphony. Rumors were everywhere. Isaak Gilkman, a friend of Shostakovich, recalled seeing the secretary of the Union Composers, V.E. Iokhelson, and an official from the headquarters of the city’s Communist Party apparatus come to rehearsal the morning of its debut. The director of the Philharmonic Orchestra I.M. Renzin, Shostakovich, and the two officials all went into a room together. It was only fifteen to twenty minutes before Shostakovich came out of the room, and in an expressionless tone, announced that he was cancelling his beloved 4th Symphony.14 The rumors were a plague. There were so many theories as to why Shostakovich cancelled it so close to its debut. The public followed the story, but unfortunately, no questions would be answered for decades.

What was said that morning of December 11, in that meeting, will forever be unclear. But it is clear that Shostakovich had a tremendous amount of pressure on him. The Soviet Union was oppressive and brutal during these times, and there was no doubt that fear of Stalin was a driving force in the cancellation of the 4th Symphony. In an interview in 1973, Shostakovich admitted, “I didn’t like the situation. Fear was all around. So I withdrew it.”15 Although the 4th Symphony was cancelled, it was revived and debuted in Moscow on December 30, 1961.16 The public waited twenty-five years to hear the “missing” symphony. After its revival, Shostakovich admitted that his 4th Symphony was the best thing he had ever written and that the symphony still remained dear to him after all of these years.17

“When a man is in despair, it means he still believes in something.” – Dmitri Shostakovich

  1. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 94. ↵
  2. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 9-10, 13-14, 32. ↵
  3. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 68-69. ↵
  4. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 69-70. ↵
  5. John Merriman and Jay Winter, Socialist Realism in Europe Since 1914 (Detroit: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 2006), 238, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/CX3447000806/GVRL?u=txshracd2556&sid=GVRL&xid=46ab7ff9. ↵
  6. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 76-78. ↵
  7. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 83-84. ↵
  8. Ivan Martynov, Shostakovich: The Man and His Work (New York: Philophical Library Inc), 49-50. ↵
  9. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 85-86. ↵
  10. Gale eBooks, Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series: Shostakovich, Dmitri (Dmitievich), 1906-1975 (Detroit: Gale, 2003), 356-361 Vol. 117. ↵
  11. Hiroaki Kuromiya and Noah Berlatsky, Overview of the Great Purge (Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2013),13-24, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/CX2063900010/GVRL?u=txshracd2556&sid=GVRL&xid=fe1806fe. ↵
  12. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 92-96. ↵
  13. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 95. ↵
  14. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 95-96. ↵
  15. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 97. ↵
  16. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 226. ↵
  17. Laurel E. Fay, Shostakovich: A Life (New York: Oxford Press, 2000), 226-227. ↵

Tags from the story

  • 4th Symphony, Dmitri Shostakovich, Soviet Union, Stalin

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email
Amanda Uribe

Amanda Uribe

I am in the St. Mary's University Greehey School of Business studying Business Management with a track in Entrepreneurship and Innovation. I've played the violin for over a decade and I'm continuing my studies with the St. Mary's Orchestra. I have always enjoyed writing and reading historical texts.
Author Portfolio Page

This Post Has 45 Comments

  1. Maria Ferrer
    Maria Ferrer 7 Mar 2021 Reply

    Amanda,
    I really loved reading your article, and the topic you chose is very interesting. It amazes me how one moment can change your life forever. I have no idea how hard it must have been for Shostakovich to live all those years with fear and unable to show the world what he was capable of doing. I was happy to read at the very end that his 4th Symphony had its debut, later on, it was going to be disappointing not to hear the masterpiece Shostakovich had worked on for long and with so much passion.

  2. Avatar
    Alvaro Garza 25 Jan 2021 Reply

    Although Shostakovich had an immense love for music and an undoubtable talent for composing, I’m glad he didn’t debut his symphony. He had a lot to lose and his family was ultimately the most important thing. Stalin’s anger towards Shostakovich goes to show how moving his music was and how much influence it had. The 20 year late debut of the missing symphony is a great end to the story, as he was still able to share his greatest work with the world despite the obstacles he faced in his life.

  3. Avatar
    Sophia Rodriguez 4 Oct 2020 Reply

    We never talk about music history and how significant music is in our life. I thought Shostakovich music was amazing and last year I remember my high school band was going to play his Symphony No. 5 Finale. He is a genius composer and I never knew how much he feared because of Stalin. I did not even know he cancelled his whole 4th Symphony because of his fear of being captured.

  4. Avatar
    Sterling Henarie 2 Oct 2020 Reply

    In school, they never even mentioned the oppression of the arts in Stalin’s Russia so this was very interesting to read about. Considering all of the things that Stalin did during his reign, I’m impressed that Shostakovich even attempted to debut his 4th symphony. I can’t help but wonder what music and art we missed out on because of Stalin’s oppression.

  5. Savannah Palmer
    Savannah Palmer 19 Sep 2020 Reply

    I have always admired the way in which Shostakovich wrote his music, especially his symphonies. I find it so interesting that Shostakovich dealt with so much censorship during this lifetime, and yet he wrote such tremendous works. It reveals how passionate Shostakovich was about music. The courage to continue to write a piece, even though there will be repercussions, signifies one talents and true love for music. He will truly be remembered as a legendary composer who wrote some of the most memorable works.

Comments navigation

Previous commentPrevious

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

StMU History Media

A Student Organization of St. Mary's University of San Antonio Texas

Sponsors

  • College of Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences, St. Mary's University
  • Department of History, St. Mary's University
  • Department of Political Science, St. Mary's University
  • Center for Catholic Studies, St. Mary's University

Support Services

  • The Learning Assistance Center, St. Mary's University
  • Louis J. Blume Library Services, St. Mary's University
  • STRIVE Career Center, St. Mary's University
  • Academic Technology Services, St. Mary's University

About

  • About Us
  • Our Authors
  • Our Archive
  • Contacts

© All rights reserved

Twitter
Facebook
Pinterest