The Corpse Without Peace: Evita

“Cadáver momificado con Dr. Pedro Ara” | Eva Perón’s corpse embalmed with Dr. Pedro Ara| 1954 | Francisco Bolsíco, E F CA | Courtesy of Archivo Grande de la Nación

Winner of the Fall 2018 StMU History Media Award for

Best Descriptive Article

The echo of her name still resonates in the hearts of Argentinians and others inspired by her. In life and in death, she was the vivid fire and image of revolution that was never extinguished. Born as Eva María Duarte, married to Juan Domingo Perón, she was the woman named by the people as Evita.

During the 1940s, Argentina experienced pivotal political changes that provoked a long battle of political struggles. Opposing ideologies—left and right—on the two forces of the political spectrum clashed. The left’s party gained momentum since they advocated equality, which appealed to most of the Argentinian population. Juan Domingo Perón was the man on the left who promised Argentina access to education, health care, and women’s rights, just to name a few.1 However, it was his wife, Eva Perón, who moved masses and won Argentina’s heart and trust. Through Peronism, the political movement that promoted social justice and equality, the thinking of many Argentinians started changing.

In 1946, Eva Perón became the First Lady of Argentina, and it was then that her popularity started growing. Not many knew much about the actress who married the future president of the nation, but soon enough, she would become one of the most notorious figures of Argentina. She revolutionized the role of a First Lady, by defying societal conventions. Unlike other women who had held her position, Evita played a humanitarian role. She tirelessly worked with the poor, the working class, and women. The Eva Perón foundation, administered by herself, provided financial assistance to hundreds of people every day. Her work consisted of the creation of schools, health care, and rights for the working class.2 Eva Perón was named Argentina’s spiritual leader. During Perón’s second term as president, the people demanded that Evita run for vice president. The opposing parties despised her for her great popularity and her humanitarian works.3

And so, Evita ran for vice president of Argentina. During her campaign, however, she was diagnosed with uterine cancer. However, she was not told the fatal diagnosis of her illness at the time. Today, scientists know that Evita developed uterine cancer because Juan Perón was a carrier of Human Papillomavirus (HPV). Everyone witnessed the slow deterioration of her body but never of her spirit. The predictions were that Evita and Perón were both going to win by a considerable margin. Unfortunately, she had to withdraw from the election because she was continually growing weaker. On her death bed, Evita voted for the first time, because this was the first election in which women were able to vote, and partly because of her influence in obtaining voting rights for women in Argentina.4 Nurses who looked after Eva described her to be in incredible pain during her last days. Sometimes she would spend a whole day sedated with morphine.

“Calbido Abierto del Partido Peronista” | Millions of spectators listening to Evita’s speech during her candidacy| August 31, 1951| Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

On the morning of July 26, 1952, it was announced to the Argentinian nation that the “abanderada de los humildes y enfermos” had passed away.5 It took twenty-five years and a long journey for her remains to be finally buried. Argentina started its eternal mourn. Before Eva’s passing, Perón hired Dr. Pedro Ara, the man who would immortalize her remains.6 He was a young doctor popular for his impeccable work at embalming. Perón demanded that he complete his work at the headquarters of the CGT (Confederación General del Trabajo de la República Argentina). Dr. Ara prepared Evita’s corpse for the long funeral that was to come. A lot of people were expected to attend; however, the number of people that came to mourn Evita was impressive. It is estimated that two million Argentinians came to see her. For sixteen days and nights, multitudes visited their first lady. The pope received 160,000 petitions to make her a saint.7 Argentina and Chile ran out of flowers because of how many offerings were brought to her. The funeral had to be suspended because Dr. Pedro Ara was afraid that if it took too long, he might not be able to finish the embalmment of her corpse.

Dr. Pedro Ara was very talented at his job. He had a “secret” formula to preserve bodies impeccably. For an entire year, he embalmed and preserved Evita’s corpse. She was his greatest masterpiece. The goal was not only to preserve, but to immortalize her remains as if she were living. Some described her looking like a doll or as herself but not dead, just in a profound sleep. Dr. Ara wrote El Caso Eva Perón, a book describing the meticulous work done to preserve her remains. He would inject into her system everyday his “secret” formula.

As Dr. Ara worked to preserve Evita, Perón’s popularity started to decline. The opposing parties took advantage of Evita’s absence. Many attempts were made that tried to remove Perón from power. Finally, in September of 1955, Juan Domingo Perón was removed from power by the Liberation Revolution, led by Pedro Eugenio Aramburu. With Aramburu’s regime, which lasted three years, everything that had to do with Juan Domingo Perón and Eva Perón was banned. Because of that, Perón was sent into exile.8

By then, Dr. Ara had already finished his work and had left Evita in perfect condition, as if she were still alive. However, her corpse was still at the CGT. This was a problem because the rivalry between Perónists and Anti-Perónists was turning more violent. Perónists were trying to steal Evita’s corpse, while the government threatened to throw the corpse into the sea.9 The ruling government was unsure where Evita’s body was. When they found the corpse at the CGT, they had to perform a series of tests to determine whether it really was her, not because of the normal decay a body undergoes, but because of the perfect state the corpse was in. A piece of her ear was removed along with a finger in order to determine if the doll-like corpse was indeed her. In the process, they discovered that Evita had undergone a lobotomy. There is no evidence that supports that Evita was aware of this, let alone that she had consented to the procedure. The government finally took possession of the CGT and Evita’s corpse. The whereabouts of her corpse remained extremely confidential. It was unknown to Argentinians if she was even still in the country. The government was concerned that the presence of her corpse might ignite a revolution.10

On November 22, 1955, Evita’s corpse was assigned a guardian, Colonel Carlos Eugenio de Moori Koenig. His duty was to protect the corpse and keep it hidden from revolutionaries. These, however, were not the instructions he decided to follow. It is argued that he stole the corpse from the CGT and took her to his private office. There, Moori kept Evita as a trophy. Often, he invited guests and showed them that she was in his possession. More disturbing than his garish display of Evita’s corpse were the sexual acts Moori Koenig engaged in with Eva Perón’s corpse. Rumors said that Moori Koenig was infatuated with Eva during her lifetime and that he had developed a sick obsession with her while having custody of her corpse. Fortunately, this information reached high ranking officers. When the government found out about his behavior, Moori Koenig was immediately discharged from his position and Evita was taken away from him. Everywhere Moori Koenig had secretly taken the corpse, roses and offerings were left for Evita. This made him believe that he was being followed.11

“Funeral de Evita” | Millions of Argentinians mourning Eva Perón during her funeral | July 29, 1952| Andrew Parodi | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

A new guardian was assigned to the remains of Eva Perón. Colonel Hector Cabanillas was the man who took the responsibility and mission of caring for Eva Perón’s corpse. This mission was of great importance because the slightest mention of her existence resulted in revolts and a threat to the political situation of Argentina. It was decided that it would be best if Evita was buried secretly. Colonel Cabanillas was the one who elaborated the logistics of this operation. At first, the plan was to bury her under a pseudonym in Argentina. Everything was going according to the plan. During the night a man, whose name is unknown, was supposed to bury her. However, he fell asleep while waiting for everyone at the cemetery to leave. While asleep, Evita’s corpse was mysteriously stolen. Even more strange, the body was shortly recovered but there is no evidence of how12.

In April of 1967, the plan at last had success. This operation was a lot more complex and took months of planning. Eva Perón’s corpse was taken to Milan, Italy. There, she was buried under the pseudonym of Maria Maggi de Magistris, an Italian widow. Even the people who despised her recognized her courage and strength as a woman. When buried in Milan, she was buried standing up. That was how Eva Perón lived her life, as a woman who would never bow down for anything she didn’t believe in, and as someone who would stand up for the weak and ill.13

Fourteen years of dictatorships and weak democracies had governed Argentina. The lack of political structure and stability made Evita even more popular. They wanted the “reina de los descamisados” to be back home. The place of her grave was a mystery to them. Many wondered whether she was ever buried at all. Eventually, the revolts became so acute that Aramburu was threatened. Although there is still speculation around the details surrounding his death, on June 1, 1970, Pedro Eugenio Aramburu was murdered. The main theory consists of him being kidnapped and murdered as part of a demand for the return Perón, and for Evita’s corpse. The pressure Perónists exerted produced fruit on September 1, 1971, when Evita was exhumed from her grave in Italy and transported to Madrid, were Juan Perón was living in exile. In the process of her exhumation, the workers involved were astonished to find a woman buried years ago in perfect condition. Dr. Pedro Ara was invited to inspect the corpse to determine if the corpse was indeed her. He confirmed that the woman buried as Maria Maggie de Magistris was Eva Maria Perón, and that she was in the exact perfect condition he had left her in 1953. Nonetheless, her family disagreed with this statement. They described how her feet, nose, ears, and fingers were damaged, most likely because of all the moving and corruption. Her feet were said to be damaged because of being buried on her feet.14

Eva Perón | 1947 | Francisco Bolsíco, E.F.C.A | Courtesy of Archivo Grafico de la Nación

Perón was at last in custody of his beloved Evita. At this point, he already had another wife, Maria Martinez. She had admired Evita and the work she had done in her lifetime. For Maria, it was an honor to be in her presence. Every day, she would kindly brush through Evita’s blonde hair.15

Someone else in Perón’s house was infatuated by Evita: Jose Lopez Reja. He, like Moori Koenig, engaged in sexual acts with Evita’s remains. This time, Perón’s wife joined him. There is no evidence that indicates whether Perón was aware of this behavior or not.

With Aramburu dead and Evita’s whereabouts now known to Argentinians, Perón was able to return from exile. He came back to Argentina and started his third presidency in May of 1973. It came as a surprise to Argentinians that Perón didn’t bring Evita’s remains with him.16 Enraged, Montoneros, a group of radical Perónists, stole Aramburu’s remains from his grave. Their objective was to exchange Aramburu’s remains for Evita’s. When Perón died in 1974, his third wife, Maria Martinez, finally brought Evita’s remains back to Argentina. Once again, Evita was mourned for several days by Argentina, but this time she was beside her husband. Perón and Evita were united once again when buried at the presidential residence, Los Olivos. This was supposed to be temporary, because the Altar de la Patria was being constructed by Maria Martinez. However, she was removed from power in 1976 by Jorge Rafael Videla, resulting in the projected mausoleum never to be finished.17

In 1976, Evita and Perón were divided one more time. She was taken away and buried in the Duarte’s family mausoleum.18 This would be the last time Eva Perón’s remains would be moved. Since then, she has been safe two-hundred meters below the ground, with her family. Eva’s grave is a site for Argentina and tourists around the world to visit. Her life, her legacy, and certainly the story of her death was immortalized.

  1.  Eva Peron, In My Own Words: Evita (Buenos Aires: New Press, 2005), 91.
  2. Eva Peron, In My Own Words: Evita (Buenos Aires: New Press, 2005), 18.
  3. Eva Peron, In My Own Words: Evita (Buenos Aires: New Press, 2005), 19.
  4. Eva Peron, In My Own Words: Evita (Buenos Aires: New Press, 2005), 14.
  5. Eva Peron, In My Own Words: Evita (Buenos Aires: New Press, 2005), 16.
  6.  John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 162.
  7. John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 167.
  8. Margaret Schwartz, Dead Matter: The Meaning of Iconic Corpses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2015), 41.
  9. John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 90-122.
  10. Margaret Schwartz, Dead Matter: The Meaning of Iconic Corpses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2015), 45.
  11. Margaret Schwartz, Dead Matter: The Meaning of Iconic Corpses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2015), 47.
  12.  John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 175
  13.  John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 177.
  14. Margaret Schwartz, Dead Matter: The Meaning of Iconic Corpses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2015), 40.
  15. Margaret Schwartz, Dead Matter: The Meaning of Iconic Corpses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2015), 43.
  16.  John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 179.
  17. Margaret Schwartz, Dead Matter: The Meaning of Iconic Corpses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 2015), 42.
  18. John Barnes, Evita, First Lady: A Biography Of Eva Perón (Indiana: Grove Press,1996), 167.

Tags from the story

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email

This Post Has 132 Comments

  1. Overall a good descriptive article, yet I feel that the introduction could have been more intriguing. I see what the author was trying to do in an emotional connection. Evita is a very interesting woman and I see that in the article. I just wished the introduction reflected the interesting points of Evita. The narrative arc is there, and I can see the capability of the author. The story line was very well done and I could imagine the scenes with her impeccable description.

  2. This is a great read. I never knew much about Argentina or any significance towards it whatsoever. Reading this article gave me a new view over this history. Evita is a very strong and independent woman with a voice that needs to be heard, making a great impact as a first lady. The way she died was so horrible yet she was a iconic female and it Is a shame that her body was handled so terribly after her death.

  3. Lindsey Wieck

    Wow! This article was really incredible. I had no idea her body was so well preserved and the journey it underwent. Fabulous storytelling! This is now a required reading in my graduate Advanced Public History methods course.

    1. Thank you Dr. Wieck! I’m glad you enjoyed this reading and that other students will be reading Evita’s story.

  4. Evita sounds like an astonishing woman, who made change and left a mark while she was here on earth. The read was awesome it left me wanting to read more. It did make me feel sad when I read about how disrespectful her body was treated. It is sad that people didnt allow her to be laid to rest, instead did horrible things. It is also sad how Love and infatuation can lead to these results. This article was very well written, thank you for the amazing read.

  5. I do not know a lot about Argentina, but this makes me want to look into more of their history. Eva Maria Peron is an outstanding woman, and it makes since why the people of Argentina loved and admired her so much. It is absolutely shocking how her body was treated after her death and I am glad that she was finally laid to rest. This is a very interesting article.

  6. This is a pretty shocking story, and definitely not what one would first expect given the amount of publicity the story has received over the years. You did a fantastic job of storytelling in this article, and the way in which something that is normally very personal became politicized is a captivating read.

  7. Great article about Latin American History. I had no idea that life in Argentina was wrought with political turmoil and revolution in the mid-twentieth century. The way Evita’s body was transferred and handled after the embalming process was very repulsive, and should serve as an example to how revolting greed can be. Nevertheless, Evita was a truly inspiring figure for her humanitarianism.

  8. An interesting read! Given how much attraction Evita has gotten after her death, it is not hard to see why she would ultimately end up buried about 650 feet below ground. The timing of Evita’s death was very unfortunate since she died at a time when Argentina was undergoing significant political changes and needed strong figures to guide it. I wonder how the pope responded to the many requests to make her a saint? Good job on the article.

  9. This was a great read. It is astonishing the lengths people will go to when they worship other people. I can understand preserving her body for the funeral, but everything that happened beyond that is rather disturbing. There were so many better options to deal with her body than the path that was taken. I understand how some people have a hard time letting go, but this was an almost unreal case. I guess we can be thankful that no one has tried to turn this part of the story into Evita 2.

  10. I don’t know much of anything about Argentina, let alone the significant figures of the country and what they stood for or what made them important. Reading this article gave me a little insight on an Argentinian historical figure, Evita. Strong minded and strong voiced, making such an impact starting off as a first lady. Dying so horribly yet standing tall showed so much strength. It was a shame to know that her body was treated so poorly for a while after her death.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Close Menu