Skip to content

featuring historical research, writing, and media at st. mary's university

  • World History

    World History

    Menu
    • World History
    • Pre-Classical History (to 600 BCE)
    • Classical History (600 BCE-600 CE)
    • Post-Classical History (600 CE-1492 CE)
    • Early Modern History (1492-1789)
    • Modern History (1789-1914)
    • Global History (1900-present)

    From the Ancient World

    Prehistoric Life, Medicine, and Its Dangers

    Posted by Ian Mcewen04/16/2021

    From the Modern World

    Rwanda Climbs One Hill After Another, But Can It Politically Transition Without Falling?

    Posted by Raul Colunga04/18/2021

    Regional Histories

    Menu
    • African and African American Studies
    • Latin American Studies
  • US History

    Early America

    Menu
    • US-Three Worlds Meet (to 1620)
    • US-Colonization and Settlement (1585-1763)
    • US-Revolution and the New Nation (1754-1820s)
    • US-Expansion and Reform (1801-1861)
    • US-Civil War & Reconstruction (1850-1877)

    The Voice that Outshined the Rest: The success of Chris Cornell

    Posted by Christian Lopez11/24/2020

    All Roads Lead to Rome: General Mark Clark's Journey to the Eternal City

    Posted by Santos Mencio03/30/2021

    When Angels Fall from Heaven: Chuck Yeager Shoots for the Stars

    Posted by Eddie Paniagua03/19/2021

    The Artistic Duo: The Inspiring Story of Jean Michel Basquiat and Andy Warhol

    Posted by Nelly Perez10/22/2019

    Fyre Festival: Trouble in Paradise

    Posted by Chelsea Alvarez05/12/2019

    BLACK LIVES MATTER- A Change in America

    Posted by Jakob Trevino11/05/2020

    Segregation and Activism: Then and Now on the Eastside

    Posted by Shine Trabucco06/10/2019

    Los Beneficios de los Programas Bilingües en los Estados Unidos

    Posted by Yamilet Muñoz12/02/2020

    "I Will Always Love You": The Dolly Parton and Porter Wagoner Love Story

    Posted by Carly Bagley03/21/2021

    Murder or “Justifiable Homicide”?: The Death of the Revolutionary Fred Hampton

    Posted by Natalie Thamm04/07/2019

    Impaled: The Impossible Story of Phineas Gage

    Posted by Isabella Torres10/01/2019

    BEYONCÉ: The Early Days of the Worldwide Legend

    Posted by Sydney Hardeman10/01/2019

    The Wet Railing that Solved the Clarence Hiller Murder Case

    Posted by Diamond Davidson04/07/2019

    Stitches of Healing: The AIDS Memorial Quilt

    Posted by Michaela Jeanis11/05/2020

    Mendez v. Westminster: Planting the seed for Desegregation

    Posted by Erin Vento11/10/2020

    The Waco Tragedy: David Koresh and The Branch Davidians

    Posted by Victoria Davis12/14/2019

    Metallica: The Tragedy Overseas

    Posted by Isaiah Torres05/08/2019

    America's Finest Hour - The Berlin Candy Bomber

    Posted by Stephen Talik02/06/2020

    Behind The Tapes: The Actions Taken Towards Impeaching Nixon

    Posted by Thalia Romo11/15/2019

    Déjà vu: “Have I been here before?”

    Posted by Emilia Caballero Carmona04/14/2021

    Walt Disney and the building of his Magic Kingdom

    Posted by Malik Heard12/06/2019

    Brian Kemp, The Puppeteer of His Own Election

    Posted by Alexa Montelongo12/01/2020

    A Company of Heroes: The Story of the Band of Brothers

    Posted by Amanda Gutierrez11/30/2020

    Radiator Springs and the Old Spanish Trail: How Pixar's Cars Reflects the History of an Old Auto Route

    Posted by S. Michael Sleeter05/12/2019

    Private Felix E. Longoria: An Affair, Some Would Rather Not Remember!

    Posted by Lulu Guadalupe Avitua-Uviedo09/20/2020

    Creating a Monster: Richard Ramirez, The Night Stalker

    Posted by Claudia Sanchez05/08/2019

    Like a Virgin: Madonna's Road to Success

    Posted by Andrea Degollado11/14/2019

    From Being a Christian and Ex-Military to being a Serial Killer: Israel Keyes

    Posted by Adrianna Hernandez10/31/2020

    ADHD Among Americans: From Childhood to Adulthood

    Posted by Josephine Tran11/15/2019

    Where Will it Lead (Pb) Us from Here: A Global Necessity or a Disaster Waiting to Happen?

    Posted by Midori Flores11/18/2020

    Contemporary America

    Menu
    • US-Industrial United States (1870-1900)
    • US-Emergence of Modern America (1890-1930)
    • US-Great Depression & WWII (1929-1945)
    • US-Postwar United States (1945-early 1970s)
    • US-Contemporary United States (1968-present)
  • Themes

    SPICE Categories

    Specialty Categories

    Special Themes

    Menu
    • Social History
    • Political History
    • Environmental History
    • Cultural History
    • Economic History
    Menu
    • Art History
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Gender Studies
    • Human Rights
    • Public Health and Medicine
    • International Relations
    • Linguistics
    Menu
    • Military History
    • Music
    • People
    • Psychology
    • Religion
    • Science & Technology
    • Sports
    Menu
    • Catholic Heritage
    • The Year 1968
    • COVID-19
    • Social Justice
    • Spanish Language
  • Showcase

    Showcase Editions

    • Vol 1 – 2016
      • Vol 1 No 1 Aug-Sep 2016
      • Vol 1 No 2 Oct-Nov 2016
    • Vol 2 – 2017
      • Vol 2 No 1 Jan-Feb 2017
      • Vol 2 No 2 Mar-Apr 2017
      • Vol 2 No 3 Aug-Sep 2017
      • Vol 2 No 4 Oct-Nov 2017
    • Vol 3 – 2018
      • Vol 3 No 1 Jan-Feb 2018
      • Vol 3 No 2 Mar-Apr 2018
      • Vol 3 No 3 Aug-Sep 2018
      • Vol 3 No 4 Oct-Nov 2018
    • Vol 4 – 2019
      • Vol 4 No 1 Jan-Feb 2019
      • Vol 4 No 2 Mar-Apr 2019
      • Vol 4 No 3 Aug-Sep 2019
      • Vol 4 No 4 Oct-Nov 2019
    • Vol 5 – 2020
      • Vol 5 No 1 Jan-Feb 2020
      • Vol 5 No 2 Mar-Apr 2020
      • Vol 5 No 3 Aug-Sep 2020
    Menu
    • Vol 1 – 2016
      • Vol 1 No 1 Aug-Sep 2016
      • Vol 1 No 2 Oct-Nov 2016
    • Vol 2 – 2017
      • Vol 2 No 1 Jan-Feb 2017
      • Vol 2 No 2 Mar-Apr 2017
      • Vol 2 No 3 Aug-Sep 2017
      • Vol 2 No 4 Oct-Nov 2017
    • Vol 3 – 2018
      • Vol 3 No 1 Jan-Feb 2018
      • Vol 3 No 2 Mar-Apr 2018
      • Vol 3 No 3 Aug-Sep 2018
      • Vol 3 No 4 Oct-Nov 2018
    • Vol 4 – 2019
      • Vol 4 No 1 Jan-Feb 2019
      • Vol 4 No 2 Mar-Apr 2019
      • Vol 4 No 3 Aug-Sep 2019
      • Vol 4 No 4 Oct-Nov 2019
    • Vol 5 – 2020
      • Vol 5 No 1 Jan-Feb 2020
      • Vol 5 No 2 Mar-Apr 2020
      • Vol 5 No 3 Aug-Sep 2020
  • About

    Course Readings

    Article Indexes

    About Us

    Menu
    • Course Readings – SC 3300 – Nash
    • Course Readings – SMC 1301 – Wieck
    • Course Readings – PO 4334 – Dr Celine
    • Course Readings _ PO 3365 – Dr Celine
    Menu
    • Course Readings – HS 2321 – Whitener
    • Course Readings – HS 2322 – Whitener
    • Course Readings – SMC 1301 – Whitener
    Menu
    • Our Article/Author Index
    • Award Winning Articles
    Menu
    • Our StMU History Media Project
    • Our Faculty Consultants
    • Our Writers
    • Contact Us
  • Descriptive Article, Human Rights, International Law, International Relations, Military History, People, Political History, United States History, US-Contemporary United States (1968-present)
  • April 16, 2020

American Enemy? Renouncing Citizenship for Freedom and Enhancing Rights for All Americans

Yasser Esam Hamdi in a prayer service at Guantanamo Bay. | Courtesy of the United States Navy.
Yasser Esam Hamdi in a prayer service at Guantanamo Bay. | Courtesy of the United States Navy.
Thiffany Yeupell

Thiffany Yeupell

Yaser Esam Hamdi, enemy? Having lived in Saudi Arabia for most of his life, Hamdi first encountered the U.S. military in 2001, when the U.S. invaded Afghanistan. As the United States mobilized for the War on Terrorism, Hamdi had naively affiliated himself with the Taliban resistance and prolonged presence in the battlefields, which led to his capture and detention in late 2001.1 As the years went on, the U.S. military declared Hamdi as an ‘unlawful combatant’, which left him to face inhumane treatment during his imprisonment in Guantanamo Bay.2 The treatment of prisoners of war is governed by one of the Geneva Conventions that recognizes the necessity of humanitarian protections for all prisoners during war times.3 Yet, Hamdi’s detainment, as an ‘unlawful combatant’ away from U.S. soil, enabled the U.S. Government to avoid following its own rules and violate the minimal protections that the Geneva Convention Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War should have afforded him. The location of Hamdi’s initial detention capitalized on this “legal black hole,” as Guantanamo Bay presented a unique case of leasing land on foreign soil, for which the traditional jurisdiction of the U.S. did not apply. Under the purpose of carrying out operations for the sake of the ‘security of the nation’, the U.S. acted with impunity in Guantanamo Bay and took full advantage of the opportunity to curtail human rights that this presented.4 Hamdi, born an American Citizen, saw his birthright protections denied not just as a Prisoner of war but as he should have been protected as an American.5 Categorizing Hamdi as an ‘unlawful combatant’ de facto removed all these rights and negated his American citizenship.

Map of U.S. Naval Base Guantanamo Bay | Courtesy of United States Navy.

American troops captured Hamdi in the battlefields of Afghanistan, where Hamdi was fighting alongside the Taliban.6 After his capture, the U.S. military categorized the same way they did for all suspected terrorists. The U.S. Government determined underhandedly that Hamdi had not fought in accordance with the specifications of the Third Geneva Convention.7 The U.S. Military transported Hamdi to Guantanamo Bay Prison in Cuba for detention. There, Hamdi joined another 600 prisoners who had been “held indefinitely, without charges, without counsel, and without access to American Courts.”8 The treatment Hamdi received denied his humanity. Even once a report with contributing information from a visiting CIA analyst exposed openly the type of torture conducted in Guantanamo Bay, the American public sentiment did not change towards the prisoners because many Americans wanted to inflict punishment for the 9/11/2001 attacks (Hamdi had nothing to do with 9/11 but his arrest in Afghanistan was enough to deny his rights too).9 Americans and the Bush Administration held Afghanistan responsible for the Saudi Arabian Terrorists who executed the 9/11/2001 attacks. Therefore, many Americans simply assumed the government was correct in its handling of anyone categorized as ‘enemy combatants’.

Prisoners in Guantanamo Bay prepped for processing | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

However, once the U.S. government came to the realization that Hamdi was an American citizen since his Saudi Arabian mother gave birth to him in Louisiana, the Pentagon transferred him out of Guantanamo into a Virginian Brig, placed under their supervision. Even with the new information shedding light on how to advance such proceedings at the hands of the military, Hamdi did not receive the due process granted by the U.S. Constitution, by his birthright.10 Held in the Brig, with no access to counsel, Hamdi remained in the dark about the charges against him. The U.S. government declared secrecy for all proceedings was required for the sake of safety and security for the country.11 Could the U.S. Government deny a U.S. citizen, right to counsel and due process, as in the case of Hamdi, simply because it considered him an ‘unlawful combatant’? Did the U.S. government have the power to deny a citizen all his constitutional rights whenever determined as an enemy of the state? How far could the government go in calling citizens enemies of the state to effectively deny all the protections given by the U.S. Constitution? It went on for years for Hamdi.

Hamdi started fighting for his constitutional rights. He made repeated attempts to assert his rights. His first two petitions, combined into No. 02-6827, by Frank Dunham and Christian Peregrim were reversed and dismissed, as the Fourth Circuit Court deemed the two individuals ineligible, considering the lacking qualifications in their relations to the petitioner, as found in Hamdi v. Rumsfeld 294 F.3d 598 (2002).12 As the back and forth rulings of the District and Fourth Circuit Courts swung between the necessary precautions for the safety of the nation and the protection of an American individual’s rights, the intervention of the Supreme Court prove necessary.13

Eventually, Hamdi’s father, Esam Fouad Hamdi, joined as petitioner and helped to bring the case before the Supreme Court, with a writ of habeas corpus, No. 02-6895, which his father filed under the given code 28 U.S.C. § 2241, and it was accepted.14 Hamdi’s case was finally able to move forward with the third qualified petition, as the two previous petitions failed due to the lack of a substantial relationship necessary for filing.15 With the ultimate judicial power to determine the case of Hamdi, the precedent set by his case was momentous, for all those involved in the Middle East conflict and any other future conflicts that might befall on the U.S. in the future.16 Even if declared ‘unlawful combatants’, American prisoners can access the same rights and protections from the government, guaranteed in the Constitution for each citizen.17 This casebrought to the forefront the accessibility of habeas corpus.18

Guantanamo Bay Protesters walking down the street in prisoner clothing| Courtesy of Flickr.

On June 28, 2004, the Supreme Court ruled in the favor of Hamdi in a 6-3 ruling, determining his entitlement to some protections granted by the rights like any other American, despite his ‘unlawful combatant’ status. The Supreme Court granted him habeas corpus but allowed his trial to be conducted as a military tribunal which did not afford him a jury of his peers.19 Thus, Hamdi’s case warranted a necessary judicial review so that the Executive cannot alone determine the entire case of a person who fit the same criteria as Hamdi. Justice Sandra Day O’Connor gave the plurality opinion of the court, highlighting the areas of concurrence among the justices, with multiple interpretations spanning the opinion.20

Despite all the judicial proceedings that had taken place for Hamdi’s case, in the end, Hamdi renounced his American citizenship. Given the opportunity to expatriate himself in exchange for his freedom or to remain an American citizen and stay in prison while undergoing a military trial, Hamdi chose to be exclusively a Saudi Arabian citizen. After Hamdi officially renounced his American Citizenship at the U.S. Embassy in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, he was set free. Hamdi can no longer regain American citizenship because of the restrictions placed on him based on his alleged ties to the Taliban resistance when he was captured in 2001.21 The American citizen who most meaningfully impacted the rules of habeas corpus and the proceedings of the U.S. Military and the U.S. Government when categorized as ‘unlawful combatants’ ended up exchanging his American Citizenship and denied rights for his Saudi freedom instead. This case reaffirmed the true minimum human rights that should be afforded to all U.S. citizens regardless of their actions, the way the U.S. Constitution intended it.

  1. O’Connor, “HAMDI V. RUMSFELD,” Legal Information Institute (Legal Information Institute, June 28, 2004), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/03-6696.ZO.html). ↵
  2. Daniel E. Brannen Jr., Richard Clay Hanes and Rebecca Valentine, <em>Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America</em>, (Detroit, MI, 2011), 694. ↵
  3. Geneva Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, 75 U.N.T.S. 135, entered into force Oct. 21, 1950. ↵
  4. David C. Carlson, Cuba, (Detroit, MI: 2012), 441-445. ↵
  5. U.S. Constitution, amendment. I-XXVI, (Philadelphia, PA) entered into force September 25, 1789. ↵
  6. Encyclopedia of the Supreme Court of the United States, 2008, s.v. “Hamdi v. Rumsfeld, 542 U.S. 507 (2004),” by David Luban, 385. ↵
  7. International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Geneva Convention Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War (Third Geneva Convention), 12 August 1949, 75 UNTS 135, 96-97. ↵
  8. International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, 2008, s.v. “Guantanamo Bay” 393. ↵
  9. The Encyclopedia of Middle East Wars: The United States in the Persian Gulf, Afghanistan, and Iraq Conflicts, 2010, s.v. “Guantanamo Bay Detainment Camp,” by Stephen A. Atkins. 502. ↵
  10. U.S. Constitution, art. 1, (Philadelphia, PA) entered into force September 25, 1789. ↵
  11. Encyclopedia of the Supreme Court of the United States, 2008, s.v. “Hamdi v. Rumsfeld, 542 U.S. 507 (2004),” by David Luban, 385-386. ↵
  12. United States Court of Appeals, “HAMDI v. RUMSFELD: 294 F.3d 598 (2002): 4f3d5981838,” Leagle (United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit.https://leagle.com/images/logo.png), accessed March 31, 2020, https://www.leagle.com/decision/2002892294f3d5981838. ↵
  13. Daniel E. Brannen Jr., Richard Clay Hanes, and Rebecca Valentine, Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America, (Detroit, MI, 2011), 694. ↵
  14. O’Connor, “HAMDI V. RUMSFELD,” Legal Information Institute (Legal Information Institute, June 28, 2004), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/03-6696.ZO.html. ↵
  15. Eastern District Court of Virginia, accessed March 31, 2020, http://www.vaed.uscourts.gov/notablecases/hamdi/chronology.html). ↵
  16. Daniel E. Brannen Jr., Richard Clay Hanes and Rebecca Valentine, Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America, (Detroit, MI, 2011), 694. ↵
  17. U.S. Constitution, article 1, (Philadelphia, PA) entered into force September 25, 1789. ↵
  18. Oxford English Dictionary Online, s.v. ‘habeas corpus,’ accessed March 2, 2020, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/82954?rskey=zreWpy&result=1&isAdvanced=false. ↵
  19. Daniel E. Brannen Jr., Richard Clay Hanes and Rebecca Valentine, Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America, (Detroit, MI, 2011), 696. ↵
  20. Daniel E. Brannen Jr., Richard Clay Hanes, and Rebecca Valentine, Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America, (Detroit, MI, 2011), 695. ↵
  21. Ben Herzog, Revoking Citizenship: Expatriation in America from the Colonial Era to the War on Terror, (New York, 2015), 116. ↵

Tags from the story

  • Enemy Combatant, Guantanamo Bay Detention, Habeas Corpus, Human Rights Violations, Supreme Court, torture, Yaser Esam Hamdi

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email
Thiffany Yeupell

Thiffany Yeupell

Author Portfolio Page

This Post Has 32 Comments

  1. Avatar
    Faith Chapman 28 Feb 2021 Reply

    I’m confused; if Hamdi renounced his American citizenship, what was stopping the US government from placing him back at Guantanamo Bay Prison and resuming his inhumane treatment, as he was still categorized as an “unlawful combatant” at this point (right?), or had the War on Terrorism (or the battle against the Taliban) been effectively concluded and the other prisoners of war had been dealt with already?

  2. Avatar
    Aleea Costilla 18 Oct 2020 Reply

    Prior to reading this article I did not know of Hamdi’s story, but I was aware of the Guantanamo Bay’s Prison for suspected terrorists. It is terrible that Hamdi had to endure such harsh treatment for his involvement with the Taliban. I understand the group has done many horrible things but the case of Hamdi should not have involved stripping him of his constitutional rights. I was shocked to see he renounced him American citizenship, but his history with American law must have been reason enough to not feel protected.

Comments navigation

Previous commentPrevious

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

StMU History Media

A Student Organization of St. Mary's University of San Antonio Texas

Sponsors

  • College of Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences, St. Mary's University
  • Department of History, St. Mary's University
  • Department of Political Science, St. Mary's University
  • Center for Catholic Studies, St. Mary's University

Support Services

  • The Learning Assistance Center, St. Mary's University
  • Louis J. Blume Library Services, St. Mary's University
  • STRIVE Career Center, St. Mary's University
  • Academic Technology Services, St. Mary's University

About

  • About Us
  • Our Authors
  • Our Archive
  • Contacts

© All rights reserved

Twitter
Facebook
Pinterest